Biodegradable
Definition
Overview
Biodegradable materials break down into elements found in nature when exposed to light, air, and moisture. The core elements at the end of decomposition are carbon dioxide, water, naturally occurring minerals, and biomass. Bacteria, algae, and fungi are microorganisms that assist the biodegradation process.
Though this term is widely used, there is no scientific parameter for how long something has to biodegrade so it's misleading and often a sign of greenwashing. Materials cannot be partially biodegradable. They are either 100% biodegradable or not at all. The trouble is that many materials biodegrade and they do so at vastly different rates. So while a box takes a few months to biodegrade and a plastic bottle takes a few hundred years1, they are both technically biodegradable.
Why choose it
Considering how long your packaging takes to break down is a good first step in understanding its impact on the planet. The following table shows how long different items take to decompose.
Vegetables |
5 days – 1 month |
Paper |
2–5 months |
Cotton t-shirt |
6 months |
Wool socks |
1–5 years |
Milk cartons |
5 years |
Leather shoes |
25–40 years |
Nylon fabric |
30–40 years |
Aluminium cans |
80–100 years |
Styrofoam cup |
500-1,000 years |
Plastic bags |
500-1,000 years |
Glass bottles |
1 million years |
Why not choose it
Because there are no scientific or legal parameters on the term "biodegradable," compostable is a better choice. Compostability is bound by the parameters of regulations and certifications, furthermore it requires that materials aid in the production of healthy soil as they decompose.
Without a defined length of degradation, biodegradability can be a red flag for greenwashing. For example a claim like “made with 60% biodegradable materials” may inspire consumer confidence, but the product still contains non-biodegradable materials that won’t break down. Also, some plastics that are technically biodegradable in composting facilities can be slow to biodegrade in marine environments, proposing a health risk to marine life2.
If biodegradable materials enter a landfill and decompose in this anaerobic environment, they release methane3, a greenhouse gas far more potent that carbon dioxide. So proper communication about disposal and access to composting facilities is important.
Also be wary of oxo-degradable plastics which is traditional plastic with additives to expedite degradation. Oxo-degradable plastic won't break down in the anaerobic environment of a landfilll because they require oxygen. Even in the ideal environment, oxo-degradable plastics only break down into microplastics, ultimately contaminating the soil. And, while oxo-degradable plastic can be melted and made into new plastic, manufacturers likely won't accept the risk of the degradation properties affecting the longevity of a product8. The risk of premature degradation, along with the less than 10% recycling rate of plastic in the US, it's very unlikely that oxo-degradable plastics (especially films) will be recycled.
Frequently asked questions
References
-
Measuring biodegradability (Science Learning Hub Pokapū Akoranga Pūtaiao)
-
Christin Müller, Kathy Ann Townsend, Jörg Matschullat. Experimental degradation of polymer shopping bags (standard and degradable plastic, and biodegradable) in the gastrointestinal fluids of sea turtles (Science of The Total Environment, 2011)
-
LFG Energy Project Development Handbook, Chapter 1: Landfill Gas Energy Basics (EPA)
-
Joseph Greene. Biodegradation of Biodegradable and Compostable Plastics under Industrial Compost, Marine, and Anaerobic Digestion (California State University, 2018)
-
Andrew Mclauchlin, Noreen L. Thomas. Oxo-degradable plastics: Degradation, environmental impact and recycling (Waste and Resource Management, 2012)